Archibald McDougall* (1857)

Robert Mills* (1858)

David McBeath (1858 – 1859)

George F. Collins (1859 – 1890)

Arthur George Clark (1890 – 1903)

Sarah Clark (1903 – 1904)

John F. Burmister (1904 – 1911)

James McNabb (1912 – 1913)

Anne McNabb (1913 – 1915)

Thomas W. Bowie (1915 – 1924)

Thomas Edward Foley (1924 – 1932)

Samuel Neally Hillen (1933 – 1942)

William “Scotty” Hogg (1943 – 1952)

James A. Keith (1953 – 1956)

James F. Dineen (1957 – 1959)

Ross White (1960 – 1961)

Harry Ward (1962 – 1963)

Wilfred Neil Johnston (1964 – 1983)

*Maintained a lantern atop the tower